A 100-YEAR-OLD tree is at the root of a dispute between neighbours living in Lostock Hall, near Preston.

Now the common beech tree could be heading for the chop unless council planners agree to uphold the standing Tree Preservation Order.

The lone beech, which is growing right on the boundary between two gardens in Brownedge Road, has fuelled a heated debate between neighbours over ownership of the tree.

In a report to South Ribble Borough Council's Development Services Committee, Katherine and Frederick Ogden, who live on one side of the tree, are calling for it to be axed because 'it is causing structural damage' to their property.

In support of their objection, the couple have handed planners a report from a structural engineer claiming to confirm that the tree 'is causing differential settlement, by virtue of its close proximity' to their home.

But their neighbour, Mrs Roe, whose home backs onto the majority of the tree's trunk, is calling for the tree to be saved.

Now planners have to decide whether to uphold the current preservation order made three months ago to protect the tree from being felled.

But in the council report to planners officers say: 'the loss of the tree would be detrimental to amenity, to the environment and enjoyment of the public'.

And, citing a report from the council's building control officer, they argue the damage caused to the Ogden's home by the tree is of a 'relatively minor nature'.

In conclusion, officers are calling on the planners to uphold the 'Tree Preservation Order without modification'.

Mrs Roe said: "As far as I an concerned the matter has been sorted."

After taking legal advice, Katherine Ogden, said she preferred not to comment at this stage.

Councillors are expected to make a decision on the issue at a meeting of the development services committee today (Thursday).

Converted for the new archive on 14 July 2000. Some images and formatting may have been lost in the conversion.