KELLY: So little to do but made a superb save from Livingstone and a vital interception near the end...7

McATEER: 'Mugged' by late tackles a couple of times but made a good contribution...7

HDAILLY: Looked in control of virtually everything at the back until one late mistake was rescued by a team-mate. Read the game well and was almost always in the right place at the right time...8

SHORT: The Grimsby boss praised his strikers so Short and Dailly must have done plenty right as they were in charge for more or less the whole game...8

DAVIDSON: A good, solid performance and almost carved out a late winner...7

DUNN: Something looked likely to happen when he was in possession but just lacked a little bit of precision in the final third...7

CARSLEY: Two or three trademark challenges showed he is definitely on his way back...6

FLITCROFT: A busy afternoon, always looking to be involved, but has not yet recovered his powers -- especially passing...6

DUFF: Promised to be a real threat in the first half but, disappointingly, went right out of it after the break...6

WARD: Kept possession well, forced one outstanding save and worked non-stop but still can't find that ruthless cutting edge...6

BLAKE: Threatened occasionally before being injured early in the game SUBS

JANSEN: Had his moments, especially in stoppage time when he was twice denied by brilliant saves...7

FRANDSEN: Didn't really get into the game in the 15 minutes available to him.