A 'remorseless' man who was jailed for 15 years for stabbing a student eight times over a remark about a skateboard will not have his manslaughter sentence extended.
The case of Shiloh Pottinger, 20, was referred to the Attorney General’s Office under the Unduly Lenient Sentence Scheme, after he was jailed in June for killing Luke O’Connor.
Pottinger, of Wilpshire but who was living as a student in Manchester at the time, was found not guilty of Luke's murder at a trial in May, however a jury did find him guilty of manslaughter.
Pottinger was described as a bully who carried knives to feel empowered by a judge, who said he stabbed 'gentle giant' Luke O'Connor after feeling humiliated.
Pottinger claimed he had been going for a takeaway in the early hours of October 26, 2022, when he had taken a flick knife out with him.
As he walked down Wilmslow Road around 2am, he encountered Luke and his friends, who were on their way home from a party.
One of Luke's friends made a comment about a skateboard Pottinger was carrying, which he didn't take lightly to, and challenged the group.
The court heard how Luke stepped in to intervene and it was at this point Pottinger pulled the knife out of his pocket, before hitting Luke with the skateboard.
It was heard Luke laughed at Pottinger and pushed him away before the then 19-year-old stabbed him eight times with the knife.
Pottinger's defence was that Luke made him do the act, as he and his friends had been goading him about the skateboard, which humiliated him.
Recorder of Manchester Judge Nicholas Dean KC rejected Pottinger's version of events, and said he did not believe the music student had mistakenly picked up the flick knife, saying he was carrying it as a "fashion accessory".
The judge ruled he must serve at least 10 years of his 15 year sentence before being considered for release.
In sentencing, Judge Dean said: "Luke's parents, who described him as kind, a gentle giant, with a heart of gold.
"As is to be expected, the effect of Luke's death has been profound. Luke's family are broken, distraught, and will never fully heal. They will learn to live again but only because Luke would want them to
"Luke stood up to bullies. He stood up to you.
"As Luke's mother said, there is one person responsible for Luke's death that night - that person is you Shiloh Pottinger.
"You have taken no responsibility and shown no remorse, any remorse is for yourself only.
"You said you carried a knife for empowerment, a more mature 19-year-old would not have done that.
"You attacked Luke because he laughed at you and humiliated you.
"Your interests in knives, your actions on October 25 and 26 and your actions after indicate a degree of immaturity.”
The Attorney General’s Office considered if there were grounds to refer Pottinger’s case to the Court of Appeal for being unduly lenient following a referral from a member of the public.
However, a decision was made not to refer it under the Unduly Lenient Sentence Scheme, meaning Pottinger’s sentence will remain the same.
If it had been referred, judges at the top court in the land may have heard the case and then made a judgment; either agreeing it was unduly lenient and extending the sentence, disagreeing and leaving the sentence the same, or they may even have refused to hear the case at all.
If it had been referred, there was no guarantee Pottinger’s sentence would have been extended.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereLast Updated:
Report this comment Cancel